Posts tagged ·

post processing

·...

Adobe LR 2.0 profiles compared to Capture NX profiles, landscapes

2 comments

As explained in http://blog.anands.net/2008/08/07/camera-profiles-beta-in-lightroom-20/, I started to compare camera profiles for Nikon D300 in LR 2.0 and NX.

Here is a comparison for a landscape image, shot earlier in 2008 in Yosemite National Park.

NX camera standard

NX camera standard

LR Camera Standard

LR Camera Standard

NX Neutral

NX Neutral

LR Neutral

LR Neutral

NX Vivid

NX Vivid

LR Vivid

LR Vivid

NX D2X Mode1

NX D2X Mode1

LR D2x Mode 1

LR D2x Mode 1

NX D2X Mode 2

NX D2X Mode 2

LR D2x Mode 2

LR D2x Mode 2

NX D2x Mode 3

NX D2x Mode 3

LR D2x Mode 3

LR D2x Mode 3

LR Landscape

LR Landscape

My verdict. It is very close again. I really do not see much difference in using either LR and NX now.

Processing Nikon D300 images with Capture NX and Adobe Lightroom

1 comment

As I briefly touched upon in my Nikon D300 compared to Nikon D80 I saw huge differences in processing Nikon D300 NEFs in Capture NX vs Adobe Lightroom.

Here is the same ISO 800 image edited in NX and LR adjusted only for contrast. Click on the images for bigger sized photos.

1. Default noise reduction

Edited in Adobe Lightroom

Edited in Adobe LightRoom without additional noise reduction

Edited in Capture NX

Edited in Capture NX without additional noise reduction

100% crop of Adobe LightRoom

Adobe LightRoom 100% crop

100% crop of Capture NX

Nikon Capture NX 100% crop

IMO, Capture NX is way better out of the box.


2. Increasing Noise Reduction in Adobe Lightroom

Image adjusted in Adobe Lightroom by increasing luminance NR and sharpening

Adobe LightRoom edited photo after adjusting Luminance NR and sharpening

LightRoom crop after tweaking NR in Lightroom

LightRoom 100% crop after tweaking Noise Reduction in LightRoom



3. Images edited with no sharpening and no noise reduction

Adobe lightroom no sharpening, no noise reduction, 100% crop

Adobe Lightroom, no sharpening, no noise reduction

Capture NX no sharpening, no noise reduction

Capture NX, no sharpening, no noise reduction

Adobe Lightroom no sharpening, no noise reduction

Adobe Lightroom, no noise reduction, no sharpening, 100% crop

Capture NX, no sharpening, no noise reduction, 100% crop

Capture NX, no sharpening, no noise reduction, 100% crop



4. Photos edited with just Sharpening turned off

Adobe Lightroom no sharpening extra noise reduction

Adobe lightroom, no sharpening, extra noise reduction

Capture NX no sharpening default NR
Capture NX, no sharpening, default noise reduction

Adobe Lightroom no sharpening, extra NR, 100% crop
Adobe Lightroom no sharpening, extra NR, 100% crop

Capture NX, no sharpening, default NR, 100% crop

Capture NX, no sharpening, default NR, 100% crop

IMO, Capture NX delivers much better image quality in every possible setting.